|
Quest
News Volume 12 No. 26 January 19, 2006
Compiled
& written by Mike Fitzpatrick
Action Wisconsin
Wins $87,000 In Storms’ Lawsuit
Louisiana Preacher Will Appeal
Decision In Ovadal-Inspired Suit - Lawyers To Get Winnings
Madison - Wisconsin’s
largest gay rights group has been awarded $87,000 in attorneys’ fees by
a judge who verbally spanked a   Louisiana
“pastor” and his lawyer for bringing a frivolous lawsuit claiming the
group defamed him.
Grant Storms had claimed in the lawsuit that Action Wisconsin
defamed him by saying remarks he made at the “First International
Conference on Homo-Fascism,” advocated the murder of gays. The day-long
conference was held in Milwaukee in October, 2003 and sponsored by the
now-defunct Wisconsin Christians United.
But in a ruling last week, Milwaukee County Circuit Judge
Patricia McMahon said the AW’s interpretation of the remarks was
reasonable and the lawsuit lacked merit from the day it was filed in
February 2004. The judge also blasted Storms’ lawyer, James Donohoo of
Milwaukee, saying he should have known the complaint was a waste of
time.
However, the judge likely was unaware - on the record at least -
of Donohoo’s previous association with the primogenitor of the AW
lawsuit: self-ordained “pastor” Ralph Ovadal. Ovadal, who now operates
the self-identified “independent, unlicensed” Pilgrim’s Covenant Church
(PCC) in Monroe, sponsored the anti-gay event.
As Quest reported
last July, the genesis of the Storms lawsuit followed an ironic and,
some might say, almost comic path. Following the lightly attended 2003
Homo Fascism conference, WCU reported on its website on October 14 that
turnout at the event “included nine pastors, a state senator, a police
officer, and a number of ministry leaders” and offered for sale an
audio disc of the conference speeches. Two weeks later on October 22,
the “Reality Check” column in the gay publication Wisconsin INStep
reported that the state senator in question was “freshman Republican
Tom Reynolds, not exactly a new convert to the extremist right.”
The dual information led then AW board President Tim O’Brien to
order a copy of the conference speeches, which O’Brien listened to in
full, and AW Executive Director Christopher Ott listened to in part.
Both men were named as co-defendants in the Storm suit.
Ott later wrote a letter to then Senate Majority leader Mary
Panzer requesting her to “to investigate, identify, and discipline the
state senator “ who attended the conference. Ott included excerpts of
the Storms speech and wrote “the attendance of a state senator at this
conference is similar to a senator attending a Ku Klux Klan rally or
neo-Nazi conference, and should receive tremendous scrutiny -
especially at a time when legislators are advocating a constitutional
amendment targeted at gay people.”
The December 8 AW press release about the Panzer letter
contained similar excerpts from Storms’ speech such as “They [gays]
want to kill you;” “There is a philistine army out there. It’s called
the homosexual movement, whether you can see it or not, understand it
or not, they want to eliminate us;” and “God has delivered them into
our hands, Hallelujah – Boom, boom, boom, boom, boom [like gun fire] –
There’s twenty! Grant also made comments that suggested his supporters
go to a fast-food restaurant for a quick meal before continuing the
allegedly metaphorical massacre.
On December 8 & 9, WCU responded to the AW press release
claiming that “we had expectations that the homosexual propagandists
would prove our point about homo-fascism by screaming bloody murder and
making all sorts of wild accusations.” A third WCU press release on
December 10 promised “Action Wisconsin Will Be Held Legally Accountable
for Vicious Attack upon Christian Pastor.” A later WCU newsletter
advised Ovadal was assisting Storms in arranging for a Wisconsin
attorney. Donohoo had represented WCU in earlier cases.
Storms responded to McMahon’s award decision on January 11 by
claiming that any contention that he was advocating the murder of gays
is “ludicrous and ridiculous.” He also labeled the judge “liberal” and
“insane.”
“I was saying, the Christian community needs to go forward and
stand against the homosexual agenda,” he said, vowing to appeal the
decision. “We’ll win this case and we’ll win the cultural war. We have
God on our side.”
Donohoo also said he would appeal the awarding of attorneys’
fees, claiming the lawsuit was not frivolous. Ovadal also reinserted
himself into the fray January 12 with a press release on the PCC
website.
Action Wisconsin’s lead attorney Lester Pines said the dismissal
of Storms’ lawsuit and the declaration that it was frivolous is a
victory both for free speech and for Action Wisconsin, which is gearing
up for a major campaign against the likely November referendum on a
constitutional ban on marriage and civil unions for same sex
couples.
“This is going to be a very vicious campaign and I want
everybody to know that if they think they are going to use phony
defamation claims against Action Wisconsin to try to divert it, we will
vigorously defend them,” Pines said.
Action Wisconsin had also criticized state Senator Tom Reynolds
(R-West Allis) for attending the Milwaukee conference. Reynolds said
January 11 he stopped by for 20 minutes as a courtesy.
But as Quest also
reported last July, Reynolds has a far more involved interest with
Ovadal’s anti-gay agenda. The 2003 InStep story along with subsequent
dueling AW and WCU press releases drew the attention of Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel
political columnists Cary Spivak & Dan Bice, who followed up with
Reynolds and confirmed his presence at the Homo Fascism conference. In
their January 13, 2004 piece the columnists wrote: “ ‘It sounded
interesting,’ said the West Allis senator who owns a small print shop.
‘I don’t know much about them. I do a little printing for them.’” The
“little printing” included a number of WCU brochures. Some of WCU
titles are “A Little Discrimination Can Be a Good Thing,”
“Homosexuality: The Truth” and “Is Someone You Know A Bugger?”
Action Wisconsin executive director Chris Ott, who - along with
- was named in the lawsuit, hailed McMahon’s decision. “Action
Wisconsin will not be intimidated into abandoning our mission to
achieve full equality for LBGT citizens,” Ott said. “We did
not back down from this frivolous suit, and fought back with full
strength in order to preserve our mission. In the months and years
ahead, those who would consider suing us to silence our voice should
take fair warning from this decision: your frivolous claims will not go
unpunished.”
Pursuant to the judge’s ruling, the award will go to cover court
costs and attorney fees incurred in Action Wisconsin’s defense. The
organization is hoping to raise $5 million in its defense of marriage
equality in the coming contstitutional referendum fight.
Medicare D Snafus
Endanger Disabled PWA’s Access To HIV Meds
Madison - Problems with
Medicare D, the most far-reaching change in government benefits in
forty years, have been causing headaches for thousands of senior
citizens throughout Wisconsin since its roll out January 1. However,
for some the state’s disabled  people living with AIDS, the snafus are
threatening both short-term access to life-saving HIV medications and
possible long-term financial ruin for those whose low income isn’t
considered low enough.
Under Medicare Part D, the federal government has created
complex Prescription Drug Plans to pay pharmacies that fill Medicare
Part D prescriptions. However, many seniors and people with
disabilities have faced serious barriers getting the drugs they need
because of start-up problems with the new Medicare Part D program
and its Prescription Drug Plan
contractors.
More than 110,000 Wisconsin seniors and people with disabilities
eligible for both Medicare and Medicaid were forced into a Medicare
Part D prescription drug plan if they hadn’t voluntarily enrolled by
December 31, 2005. Many of these individuals were not
aware what plan had been chosen for them until they went to a pharmacy
to get their prescription filled. Medicare and drug plan hotlines
have been overwhelmed with calls from both recipients and pharmacies
who are trying to sort out their coverage. Case managers at ARCW, AIDS
Network and other community-based AIDS service organization offices
around the state also have spent disproportionate amounts of time
trying to help clients untangle their Medicare D mix-ups
Indeed, the first two weeks of Medicare D coverage have proved
to be a nightmare for some disabled PWA’s. Pharmacies were unable to
process claims for HIV medication refills in some cases, or payment for
medications listed on approved formularies was rejected. PWA’s who were
considered “dual-eligible” because they have both Medicare and Medicaid
were told they had large percentage co-pays, not the promised $1-5 per
drug charges. Worse yet, other PWA’s making more than 150% of
federal poverty limits - about $1166 monthly - were asked for over a
thousand dollars in medication co-pays for which there was no fix.
Because of the massive transitional problems, on January 13
Governor Jim Doyle announced that the state’s Medicaid program will pay
for one month’s of medications for all Medicare D enrollees having
difficulty with their Medicare D.
“It is outrageous how the federal government has mishandled this
program and put thousands of lives at risk,” Doyle said. “As an
emergency measure, the state will step in to ensure that no seniors go
without lifesaving medicines – but we will expect and demand that the
federal government and its contractors will not only fix the problem,
but reimburse the state.”
The Governor announced that Wisconsin will cover the cost of
prescriptions for seniors and people with disabilities that would have
otherwise been turned away because of problems with the new Medicare
Part D program. The procedures to access the short-term help were being
transmitted to social workers working with the elderly and the disabled
throughout the day.
Kathy Rogers of the Wisconsin AIDS/HIV Drug Reimbursement
Program also announced that all financially eligible ADAP enrollees
having problems with their Medicare D cards could receive emergency
assistance through that program.
Long term solutions for some PWA’s - typically those who had
been accessing Medicaid with spend downs because their income was over
the maximum permitted for automatic enrollment - may be more difficult
to quickly resolve. Because Medicare D is a federal program,
state-generated reimbursements do not count toward spend downs as they
had with Wisconsin Medicaid in the past. Thus AIDS patients who also
take a number of other brand-name medications for non-HIV related
diagnoses could find themselves paying full price for the non-ADAP
covered medications unless they select more expensive “high end”
Medicare D plans, also cost-prohibitive for most fixed income
individuals.
Legislation has been drafted to correct some of the problems
identified thus far in integrating Medicare D into the state’s existing
low income health benefit infrastructure. However, new coverage gaps
were being discovered by benefits specialists as 2005 closed,
making the likelihood a worsening crisis a possibility in the coming
months.
World & National News:
Gay Leaders Unimpressed As Alito Hearings
Conclude
Washington, DC - With
Senate Republicans holding ample votes to place Samuel A. Alito Jr. on
the Supreme Court, his confirmation hearings ended January 13.
The hearings this week gave no indications that the conservative
judge would be any more favorable to LGBT rights on the high court than his record suggests, gay rights
groups believe.
Alito, who currently sits on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the
3rd Circuit, was tapped by President Bush for the post held by retiring
Justice Sandra Day O’Connor after his first nominee, Harriet Miers,
fell through due to lack of conservative support. Alito’s nomination
was opposed by a coalition of gay rights groups, including Parents,
Families and Friends of Lesbians and Gays (PFLAG), the National Gay and
Lesbian Task Force (NGLTF), the Human Rights Campaign and the National
Center for Lesbian and Rights. The groups cited a 15-year history of
hostility toward civil rights protections during his time on the
federal bench.
Only one of the nine senators on the committee, Wisconsin’s Russ
Feingold, asked questions on LGBT issues, although Kansas Senator Sam
Brownback poke at length about gay marriage. When Feingold asked Alito
about his 2001 decision to strike down an anti-harassment policy by a
local school board, Alito defended it by saying the policy was too
broad.
On two other key LGBT questions, Alito punted, according to
Eldie Acheson, director of public policy and government affairs at
NGLTF. “Feingold asked whether Congress could legislate employment
discrimination protection and Alito said he ‘couldn’t think of a reason
why not.’ On whether federal funding could be based on a school’s
anti-harassment policy, Alito said Congress could do that ‘as long as
the condition was relevant,’ which is rather vague,” Acheson said.
Such evasiveness has become standard procedure for Supreme Court
nominees ever since Reagan’s pick, Robert Bork, was voted down in 1987
for being too outspoken. To avoid that mistake, many believe that Alito
didn’t have to disavow his conservative views, but merely obfuscate
them.
Because no new light was shed this week on Alito’s record
or his inclination to champion civil rights, those groups remained
unmoved in their belief that he should not be confirmed to the nation’s
highest court.
“I’m disappointed but not surprised by his performance,” PFLAG
Executive Director Jody Huckaby said. “He dodged important issues,
especially privacy rights, which leads me to believe he is not likely
to uphold the laws protecting the rights of all Americans.”
Democrats and like-minded legal scholars also condemned Alito’s
his theory of presidential powers - a dominant theme throughout the
hearings that was aimed at President Bush as much as at the nominee.
“In recent years, the Bush administration’s made unprecedented
claims of expansive presidential power,” said Erwin Chemerinsky of Duke
University’s law school said. Chemerinsky added it would be “too
dangerous” to allow Alito on the high court because of what he called
“a very troubling pattern of great deference to executive authority.”
Alito’s allies protested such twin assaults on the White House
and the nominee. Alito’s onetime boss in the Reagan Justice Department,
former solicitor general Charles Fried, testified that Democrats’
portrayal of the beliefs about presidential power had been “very
misleading.”
With a majority in the Senate, Republicans believe they can push
through Alito’s confirmation, unless Democratic opponents mount a
filibuster. The likelihood of such a tactic decreased January 12 when
Senator Mark Pryor (D-Arkansas) became the second of the seven
Democrats in a bipartisan group of 14 senators - who last spring
negotiated a compromise on the chamber’s handling of filibusters on
judicial candidates - to declare he did not believe Alito’s nomination
presented any “extraordinary circumstances” to warrant such a step.
Democrats are expected to exercise their right to delay the
confirmation by one week. However, Alito now is expected replace
O’Connor on the court by early February.
Virginia House
Approves Constitutional Gay Marriage Ban
Richmond - As had been
widely expected, Virginia’s House of Delegates overwhelmingly
reaffirmed its desire to add a gay marriage ban to the state’s
constitution, despite impassioned warnings that the measure would have
unintended consequences. The 73-22 vote on January sends the measure to
the Senate. If it is approved there, a referendum will be placed on the
November ballot.
In a process similar to Wisconsin’s, Virginia constitutional
amendments must pass in consecutive General Assembly sessions, with an
intervening House of Delegates election, to be placed on the ballot.
The measure was approved by a wide margin last year - an indication
that it would likely sail through again in this session.
Opponents did their best to derail the amendment, however,
arguing that it goes well beyond merely defining marriage as a union
between a man and a woman. For example, they said the amendment could
be interpreted as barring all legal recognition of unmarried family or
household members, which would erode protections for many domestic
abuse victims. According to the Virginia Sexual and Domestic Violence
Action Alliance, 60% of domestic violence victims seeking help in 2004
were not married to their batterers.
“It’s clear to me we are going much too far,” Fairfax Delegate
James M. Scott said. “Victims of domestic violence will not be able to
have their day in court.” He said he voted for the state law that
merely defines marriage as a male-female union, but that the
amendment’s additional language prohibiting recognition of civil
unions, domestic partnerships and other legal arrangements resembling
marriage are “way over the top.”
Claire Guthrie Gastanaga, lobbyist for the gay civil rights
group Equality Virginia, said voters also will not understand the full
ramifications of the amendment because the wording of the ballot
question is vague and incomplete. “The reason the proponents don’t want
it to be clear is they can’t win a fair fight,” she said.
A separate bill on the ballot question wording won preliminary
approval on a voice vote
California Social Justice Groups
Advocate For Same Sex Marriages
San Francisco - In eight
amicus briefs filed January 9 with the California Court of Appeal, more
than more than 250 religious and civil rights organizations urged the
court to put an end to state laws that deny same-sex couples the
protections of marriage.
The NAACP, Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund,
California Council of Churches, Asian Pacific American Legal Center,
and National Black Justice Coalition are among the groups filing briefs
in a landmark California court of appeal case.
“I am proud to join with other civil rights leaders in standing
up for fairness and dignity for all,” Alice Huffman, President of the
California Conference of the NAACP said in a press release announcing
the filings. “Never before has such a diverse array of groups stepped
forward to call for an end to the unfair treatment faced by same-sex
couples and their families when they are denied the ability to marry.”
“It is a matter of religious freedom to allow faith communities
to practice their faith by performing and blessing marriages between
same-sex couples who wish to make a commitment to each other, while
allowing denominations that oppose such marriages to refrain from so
doing,” California Council of Churches and California Church IMPACT
Executive Director Rick Schossler added.
More than 200 local, regional, and national religious
organizations and clergy also filed a brief arguing that the
constitutional principle of religious freedom supports the right of
same-sex couples to marry. Groups joining the brief include the United
Church of Christ, the Union for Reform Judaism, the Unitarian Church,
the California Council of Churches, California Faith for Equality, the
Ecumenical Catholic Church and the Buddhist group Soka Gakkai
International-USA.
AFA Strikes Again: Asks Ford To
Pull Gay Media Ads
Tupelo - Led by the
American Family Association (AFA), a collection of religious extremists
once again are calling on Ford to stop advertising in gay periodicals,
apparently threatening to resume a boycott if the car maker keeps
helping “groups promoting the homosexual agenda.”
“We can not, and will not, sit by as Ford supports a social
agenda aimed at the destruction of the family,” radio preachers James
Dobson, Donald Wildmon and others wrote Ford in a letter released
January 11.
Wildmon’s AFA claims Ford backs “homosexual groups
and their agenda” through things like buying ads in periodicals
marketed to the LGBT community. The AFA earlier had called off a Ford
boycott after meeting with company executives and saying the automaker
was addressing conservatives’ concerns.
Less than a week after its huddle with the AFA, Ford
said its Land Rover and Jaguar brands would stop buying ads in gay
periodicals, allegedly for business reasons. Gay groups protested,
prompting Ford initially to agree to buy some ads in gay periodicals,
but not reverse the Land Rover and Jaguar bans. Ford later said all
brands would be featured in gay media buys.
Now, the AFA is asking Ford to renew its broad ad
prohibition, halt donations to gay organizations and take other steps
the group claimed the automaker previously had agreed to. Absent such a
move, the AFA said it would “assume Ford does not intend to honor its
representations” that led to the boycott’s end.
Ford declined to directly comment on the new letter.
Industry and media analysts have categorized Ford’s handling of the
issue to date as a “public relations nightmare” and “a textbook case of
how not to respond to extremist pressure.”
Gay Activists Stage
Vatican Protest
Vatican City - Over forty
Italian gay rights activists protested outside St Peter’s Square on
January 13 , a day after Pope Benedict once again condemned same sex marriage. The
group stayed out of the square, which is Vatican territory, but held up
banners and placards criticizing the Roman Catholic Church. One banner
read “2000 years of discrimination” and said the Church should stay out
of Italian affairs.
Benedict, in an address to Italian politicians on January 12,
reiterated his opposition to gay marriages and to proposed laws
that would formally recognize the rights of gay couples.
The demonstration took place on the eighth anniversary of a
suicide by a gay man in St Peter’s Square. The demonstrators said
they also were commemorating Alfredo Ormando, a 39 year-old Italian who
set himself on fire there in 1998 to protest against the Church’s
position on homosexuality, a policy crafted by the current Pope.
Ormando later died of his injuries.
California Has Most Transgender
Friendly Laws in U.S.
San Francisco - On
January 1, 2006 two new laws solidified California’s leadership role as
the most protective state for transgender rights in the nation. The laws, sponsored by
Equality California (EQCA), were the Civil Rights Act of 2005 (AB 1400
) and the Insurance Gender Non-Discrimination Act (AB 1586). AB 1400,
authored by Santa Cruz Assemblyman John Laird, amended California’s
public accommodation law to make clear that transgender people are
protected. AB 1586, authored by Assemblyman Paul Koretz, prohibits
discrimination against transgender people by the insurance industry,
including healthcare insurers.
“By protecting transgender people and our families in education,
employment, housing, foster care, insurance, and public accommodation,
the legislature is saying very clearly that California supports
diversity and inclusion,” EQCA’s Transgender Equality California
Project Manager Danny Kirchoff said. “Across the state, employers,
schools, businesses, and government agencies are taking common-sense
steps to create non-discriminatory environments.”
After decades in which transgender people had little protection
against even the most flagrant acts of discrimination, these laws
establish that California embraces transgender people equally and
provides effective remedies for discrimination. A 2003 report released
by the Transgender Law Center (TLC) and the National Center for Lesbian
Rights, Trans Realities, documented the high rates of discrimination
experienced by transgender people. Survey respondents reported
discrimination in employment (49%), public accommodation (38%), housing
(32%), and health care (31%).
“Even today, transgender people face discrimination in virtually
every institution in the state, but these laws provide incredibly
powerful tools for creating lasting social change,” TLC Director
Christopher Daley said. “While it will take some time for the effects
of these laws to be fully felt in individuals’ lives, California’s
elected officials are to be commended for once again leading the nation
on fairness and equality.”
Sony Label "Music Wih A Twist"
Will Focus On Gay Lesbian Acts
New York - Sony Music has
announced it was launching the first major music label dedicated
to nurturing lesbian, gay, and transgendered artists. The label, Music with a Twist, is a
joint venture with Wilderness Media & Entertainment, the company
led by Matt Farber, who founded Viacom Inc.’s MTV Networks’ new gay and
lesbian channel LOGO, currently available to an estimated 20 million
homes.
The label has not yet signed any artists but plans to release
the first of a series of compilations this June during National Gay
Pride Month. The release will feature tracks from its roster of artists
as well as “gay- and lesbian-friendly” acts, according to Farber. He
says the label is not prohibiting straight artists from joining the
label, though the focus will remain on LGBT artists.
Wilderness also launched a two-hour syndicated radio show on
January 15-16 on nine FM stations, including New York, Los Angeles and
San Francisco markets. Also called Music With a Twist, the programs
will feature interviews, entertainment news and lifestyle advice - and
provide another outlet for Twist artists. Plans for more affiliates in
major markets and markets with prominent LGBT communities are in the
works. AOL Radio has also signed on to air the program over the
Internet.
New Report Suggests A “Gay
Generation Gap”
Amherst - A growing
generation gap exists in the LGBT community, posing a challenge for
social workers and activists, according to a recently released
publication by the Institute for Gay and Lesbian Strategic Studies here.
“A generation turns around in five years now,” study co-author
Janis Bohan said. The report finds the experiences of lesbian, gay,
bisexual and transgender people growing up have changed in such a
radical way that it is difficult for people five years older to fully
understand what has happened to the previous generation.
“In interviews with LGBT youth and adults, we found a noticeable
gap in communications across generations,” Glenda Russell, another
co-author said. “LGBT adults tend to project their own experiences onto
today’s young people, when in fact the lives of today’s young people
are often quite different.”
One example noted in the study was the alternative proms
organized by LGBT adults for their counterparts among high school
youth. The researchers suggested these proms are actually designed to
meet the needs of the adult organizers who missed their own proms
rather than those of today’s young people.
The researchers believe LGBT adults tend to focus on the
suffering and isolation of LGBT youth, even though many such teens are
actually doing well. “The only youth adults only see are the ones in
trouble. What we’re not noticing is the youth who are not struggling,
who have support groups and are doing just fine,” Bohan said.
However, Bohan added that young LGBT people sometimes complain
that no one is doing anything about discrimination, unaware of the
decades of prior activism.
Russell claimed the study is important because “if we don’t pay
attention to both sides of this age spectrum, we are in danger of
losing important continuity of who we are as a people and losing the
lessons that only come from the continuous understanding of history.”
“The good news is that both sides can learn from each other,”
Bohan said. “LGBT adults should be willing to follow the lead of young
people, and young LGBT people should be willing to use adults as
mentors.”
Young people often provide a fresh perspective on issues that is
both less constrained by past strategies for problem solving and less
reliant on older -- and perhaps incorrect -- assumptions about the
degree of homophobia, the report noted.
The study concluded that LGBT adults have greater experience and
resources and are more familiar with the historical roots of the LGBT
movement. But the challenge, the researchers noted, is to create
intergenerational contact. Among their suggestions was the creation of
youth panels that feature positive “coming out” stories.
State News:
ARCW To Honor Oneida Tribe, Guernsey Gala
Milwaukee - The AIDS
Resource Center of Wisconsin has announced the 15th annual Have a Heart
fund raising dinner, honoring the people who have helped pave the way in the
fight against AIDS in Northeast Wisconsin. At the annual dinner and
silent auction on February 18, ARCW will pay tribute to two long-time
donors to the agency.
The event, which will be held at the Radisson Hotel and
Conference Center at Oneida Bingo and Casino, will recognize the Oneida
Tribe of Indians of Wisconsin, a sponsor of ARCW events since 1994, and
the Guernsey Gala, the Green Bay LGBT community’s annual fund raising
pageant held since 1991, initially sponsored by area bars and
currently sponsored by Rainbow Over Wisconsin.
Originally based on the now defunct Milwaukee “Possum
Queen”project, contestants enter a dollar-a-vote contest to win
the coveted title of “Guernsey Queen.” The event has expanded to
include several major entertainment events and a softball tournament.
“The theme of this evening, ‘People: Above All Else’
honors the closing of our 20th anniversary year and a renewal of ARCW’s
commitment to putting people above all else in the fight against AIDS -
from the clients and patients we serve in Northeast Wisconsin to our
community partners,” ARCW’s Vice President and Chief Development
Officer Dan Mueller said.
The event will also commemorate ARCW’s 20th Anniversary. On
display that evening will be portraits and short vignettes of the 20
Giving 20 exhibit, highlighting 20 of Wisconsin’s leaders who have been
involved in the fight against AIDS for 20 years. Among those leaders
are Green Bay physicians Raymond Bachhuber, MD, and James Lacey, MD, as
well as ARCW Case Manager Mike Fitzpatrick.
ARCW’s 2005 Annual Report, themed “People: Above All Else” will
be unveiled at Have a Heart as well. Have a Heart benefits the AIDS
Resource Center of Wisconsin’s medical, dental and mental health care
as well as the agency’s legal, housing, food pantry and HIV prevention
services. In 2006, ARCW expects to provide care and treatment services
for a record 3,000 people.
Tickets for Have a Heart are $50 and $75. The $75 ticket
includes two complimentary cocktails, preferred seating and wine served
with dinner. To purchase tickets, please call Bill Keeton at
1-800-359-9272, ext. 1592, or email him at Bill.Keeton@arcw.org.
Tickets can also be purchased by clicking on the Have a Heart link at
www.arcw.org.
Warhol’s “Lonseome Cowboys”
Showing To Benefit Center Advocates
Milwaukee - The
Milwaukee LGBT Film/Video Festival and the UWM Union Theatre will
present a special screening of Andy Warhol’s 1968 film “Lonesome
Cowboys” Thursday, January 26 at 7pm. The screening will take place at
the UWM Union Theatre in the UWM Student Union, 2200 E. Kenwood Blvd.
Admission for this evening’s screening is free, but attendees
will be encouraged to donate to the Milwaukee LGBT Community Center
Advocates’ “No on the Amendment” Coalition. Donations of any size will
be accepted.
Festival Director Carl Bogner explained with the current
fascination with Ang Lee’s “Brokeback Mountain,” was the impetus of
what some critics call the “original gay cowboy movie.””We felt like
this was a moment ripe for exploitation, or an unasked-for addressing
of context, with this presentation of the queerest, in every sense of
the word, film Western of all time,” Bogner said
According to Bogner, Warhol’s film was originally intended as a
Western version of “Romeo and Juliet,” and adopts cowboy drag and
wears only the merest trappings of plot. “Nominally the clash between
settled folk and a rootless band of horsebacked ‘brothers’ just passing
through, the film offers a barely corralled paddock of jokiness,
flippantly held poses, and unchecked behavior,” he said. “The milieu’s
attendant homo-sociality allows a revue of masculinities
considered and a stable full of varieties of male beauty. And the
menfolk here, when not trading hair grooming tips and ballet moves,
head off into the sunset together.”
“Lonesome Cowboys” features such Warhol stars as Viva, Taylor
Mead, and Joe Dallesandro. “With Tom Hompertz lounging around as
everyone’s cowpoke of desire,” Bogner added.
“Reclaiming Moral
Values”Conference Will Have LGBT Focus
LaCrosse - The LGBT
Resource Center for the 7 Rivers Region will co-sponsor “Reclaiming
Moral Values: Faith, Sexuality and Politics,” a three-day conference,
March 3-5, at Winona State University’s Tau Center.
The conference features the Rev. Malcolm Himschoot, a
28-year-old Euro-American transgender man who preaches, teaches and  gives
presentations to all age groups throughout the country.
Himschoot also is the subject of the feature documentary “Call
Me Malcolm,” which will be featured Friday night at the conference
along with an opportunity for discussion with Rev. Himschoot. Admission
to the film is free and others are scheduled for viewing
afterward.
Also featured as a part of the conference are informational and
action workshops conducted by Rev. Anita Hill, pastor of St. Paul
Reformation Lutheran Church; Rev. Jay Weisner from Bethany Lutheran
Church in Minneapolis; Lindsey Saunders from Action Wisconsin; Monica
Meyer from Outfront Minnesota; Rev. Nancy Horvath-Zurn of Healing
Spirit Metropolitan Community Church in Rochester, MN; Daphne Burt of
Soulforce;
Rev. Gary and Rev. Mary Sue Drier of People of Hope Lutheran Church in
Rochester, MN; Emily Eastwood of Lutherans Concerned/North America; and
Greg Bonney, Attorney at Law of La Crosse.
Attendees will join other people of faith to critically assess
cultural and faith based assumptions; learn about the co-opting of
value-based principles in the current political climate; learn how to
reframe issues of morality and sexuality toward social justice; learn
about various resources and tools needed to work toward equality-based
change; and network with other activists, continue the discussion
and coordinate action efforts, locally and regionally.
Funding for the conference is provided by the Philip N. Knutson
Foundation, the Winona State University Foundation, the Elizabeth
Callender King Foundation, the Lutheran Campus Center of Winona, the
Christa Matter Memorial Fund and the LGBT Resource Center for the Seven
Rivers Region.
The registration fee is $125 for adults and $60 for students,
which includes meals, workshops, keynote presentation, and films.
Students wishing to attend only the workshops may register for a
reduced fee of $20.
Registration forms, as well as information on housing and travel
accommodations, can be found online at: www.lccwinona.org or by calling
the Lutheran Campus Center at 507-452-8316. Registration must be
received no later than February 17 and is limited to 200
participants. Early registration is recommended.
Potential LBGT attendees with questions are asked to contact
Cindy Killion by phone at: 507-457-5098 or 608-687-8294 by email at:
ckillion@winona.edu
Building Marriage Equality
Conference Set For Fox Valley
Appleton - On Saturday,
February 25 the Fox Valley Unitarian Universalist Fellowship here will
host the day-long conference “Start Now: Building Marriage Equality.”
The day will offer financial and legal planning guidance for gay and
lesbian families to help them
arrange the limited protections that are currently available, including
living wills for end-of-life decisions. Also, the conference will
provide information and training about advocating for full marriage
equality, so that gay and lesbian families may someday secure the
hundreds of rights and protections that are conferred with civil
marriage. The conference will be informative and relevant for LGBT
individual as well as LGBT allies who want to learn more about
advocating for marriage equality.
Featured presenters include Carrie and Elisia Ross-Stone of the
Rainbow Law Corporation; and Mike Tate, Campaign Manager for the “No On
The Amendment” Coalition
Carrie and Elisia have been powerful marriage equality advocates
for over 15 years. Together they founded Rainbow Law Corporation, and
since 1993 they have helped thousands of gay and lesbian families
across the nation protect themselves with estate planning. Also,
through two bicycle rides across America, they have garnered greater
awareness for the cause through media coverage and a film called
“Lesbian Grandmothers from Mars,” which documented their 2004 ride.
They were recently recognized with an “OUT 100 Award” by OUT Magazine.
Carrie and Elisia will lead sessions during the conference about
estate planning and legal needs of families. Michele Perreault, an
attorney with Madison’s DeWitt, Ross & Stevens, who practices in
the areas of family law, domestic partnership law, adoption, and
criminal defense, will also participate in these sessions to give
information and insights specific to Wisconsin. For more information
about Rainbow Law Corporation, visit: www.rainbowlaw.org
Tate is Campaign Manager for “No on the Amendment,” the
statewide effort to defeat the proposed constitutional ban on civil
unions and marriage for gay couples in Wisconsin. He is committed to
mobilizing a majority of citizens to vote against the harmful,
far-reaching amendment in November 2006. He oversaw one of the largest
grassroots voter mobilization efforts in Wisconsin political history as
the deputy director of America Coming Together in 2004. Tate was also
the state director for Howard Dean’s presidential campaign.
Tate will give the latest update on the campaign to defeat the
amendment, and Action Wisconsin staff will lead trainings during the
day to teach people how to speak effectively with friends, family and
groups about the amendment. For more information about Action Wisconsin
and “No on the Amendment,” visit: www.actionwisconsin.org
The conference is organized by Interweave, a group of more than
thirty gay and lesbian members of the Fox Valley Unitarian Universalist
Fellowship, which supports full marriage equality for gay and lesbian
unions. The conference is also sponsored by Angels of Hope MCC, a
Christian denomination primarily serving the lesbian, gay, bisexual and
transgendered community, with congregations in Appleton and Green Bay.
Additional sponsors include the GLBT Partnership, Etcetera, Harmony
Cafe, Rainbow Alliance for HOPE, and Welcoming Congregation Committee
of the First Universalist Unitarian Church of Wausau. The conference is
generously supported by Positive Voice and PFLAG Fox Cities.
Cost for the conference is $20 per person for registrations
received by February 17. Registration at the door is $25, and a special
rate of $10 is offered for students and individuals with limited income
(advanced registration preferred). The registration fee includes lunch.
Child care will be provided with an additional charge on the day of the
conference.
To register, please send your registration fee along with your
name, mailing address, phone number and email address to: Building
Marriage Equality, Fox Valley Unitarian Universalist Fellowship, P.O.
Box 1791, Appleton, WI 54912-1791.
If you have questions about the conference, please email
organizers at: startnow@fvuuf.org or call 920-882-0400, Ext. 7. You may
also call Interweave Coordinators Aaron Sherer and Paul Smith at:
920-426-4238.
Madison Night Life To Sparkle In
2006
Madison - Billing
himself as “Madison’s Favorite Socialite,” party promoter Ed Edney has
announced his personal New Year’s resolution to create a sensational
night life for the Capitol City in 2006.
The fun starts with the Heaven & Hell Party Saturday,
January 21 at the Cafe Montmarte. Guests will be coming
dressed as either the devil or our favorite angel. Edney will return to
Club Frida’s for a Valentine’s Day UnderWear Party on February 11.
Edney will then host something never done before in the state of
Wisconsin: The Suitcase Party. Final details for the March party are
being finalized. Party-goers will have to bring along their suit cases,
because Edney will send three lucky individuals along with one guest to
either Las Vegas, The Wisconsin Dells, or the Madison Hilton for the
weekend - directly from the party. Winners without suit cases at the
ready will automatically forfeit their trip.
For more information about Edney’s party schedule, look online
at: www.EdEdneyProductions.com
Feature Story:
Amputee Identity Distorder: Rare &
Misunderstood
by Ed Cushman
Some people out there actually want to be an amputee in
one form or another. They want to be missing a limb or a hand.
These people will often go to great lengths in the form of “accidents”
to remove the unwanted body part. Many often have had an  encounter
with a person who was missing part of their body when they were very
young. This experience seems to make a great impression on their psyche
which stays with them throughout their lives. They are not otherwise
mentally deranged. Some get along in spite of their need, others
eventually take drastic steps to make their desire become reality.
In recent years this this condition has become identified and is
called AID, or Amputee Identity Disorder. It’s a condition in
which the individual has a desire to be come an amputee in one form or
another. Some wish to be missing a leg(s), a hand or even a whole arm.
They usually do not know why they feel this way, but research has found
that many have had an encounter with an amputee at an early age, which
seems to have made a great impression on their subconscious. These
feelings often don’t surface for many years. I have come to know some
AID sufferers personally. Lets look into some of their lives in an
effort to better understand this condition.
"Carlos" came to America from south of the border in his teens.
When he was about six years of age, he saw a one-handed man who wore a
hook. He and his father were walking down a street in Central America
when a well-dress hombre stepped out of a car and confidently strolled
across the street and into a building in front of them. Carlos only saw
his hook for only a few seconds, but he remembered it for ever. He was
left with a burning desire to be one-handed.
After he graduated from high school in the U.S. mid west, he
worked at a machine shop where he staged an "accident" to cut off his
hand. His desire to become an amputee was very strong. The event took
off his intended hand, but also accidently amputated most of his "good"
hand too. He was left without a thumb and only two useful fingers on
his remaining hand. His recovery was long and painful. Intentional
amputation “accidents” can be risky.
Life with one hook and two only somewhat useful fingers was very
difficult for Carlos, and the pain in his remaining partial hand
continued.
Fortunately his girlfriend was very understanding–she was a very
rare individual. He had told her about his elective amputation when
they first met and she had no problem with this unusual desire. She was
eager to help him with his disability. To improve his life they
considered every possible alternative, including amputation of his
partial hand and continuing life with two hooks.
They decided to try to save and improve the functionality of his
partial hand and he underwent reconstructive surgery where one of his
toes was transplanted to replace his missing thumb. It was successful
and at last he had a more functional hand and could continue his life
as a college student. Here is an example of how things can easily go
wrong in a staged accidental amputation.
Then there is "Frank," who first encountered an amputee when he
was about five. The man who came to clean their furnace each fall had a
hook instead of a right hand, which Frank remembered clearly. Frank has
wanted to be an amputee ever since. He told me that this desire has
made life very difficult for him over the years and probably was a
contributing factor in the failure of his marriage. He never expressed
his amputation desire to his wife.
After reading my first book, “Losing A Hand,” he eventually
gathered enough courage to write to me under an assumed name and e-mail
address, and eventually we talked by telephone. He used a fictitious
name, as he was very concerned about his amputation desire becoming
known. I was the only person he ever confided in. As an engineer, he
was worried about becoming incapacitated and not being able to support
himself if he were to have only one hand. He lived in a rural area and
was physically very active.
Long before he contacted me, he constructed his own working
prosthesis. He bound his hand up inside it and tried doing the daily
tasks he would encounter as an amputee. Later, through the course of
many hours of telephone conversations with me, he became convinced that
living with a hand amputation wouldn't be a problem. Fortunately I had
something like 30 years of experience to relate to him and I could be
very truthful in answering his questions. In our conversations I was
always very careful not to be persuasive, but to try to be truthful and
factual about how I get along with one hand so he could come to his own
conclusions.
Eventually Frank "did it." he became an amputee through a staged
accident. Fortunately I'm able to report that his loss has been very
successful and he is now a very happy amputee. He had far less pain
than I encountered and much less than even he expected. He had little
difficulty adapting to using one hand while his stump healed. He was
very pleased when he got his prosthesis and related that he wished he
had done it when he was in his 20s and had not waited so long.
Because he had a very positive outlook, his friends took his
"accident" in stride and he went on with his life as if nothing ever
happened. This is a case of a very successful elective self-amputation,
in part due to much careful planning and research. Frank wanted to
understand all of the implications of being an amputee. He did not rush
into it. He realized that amputation was not to be taken lightly.
Some AID sufferers can never bring themselves to actually
perform a voluntary amputation. Such was the situation with "Sam" who
contacted me by e-mail with a few questions after reading a story I
wrote for the inter net site www.secretgardenstories.org.
Editors Note:
SecretGardenStories.com contains many works of fiction including a high
percentage from gay men, however the site has not been available
lately, at least on my computer.
He intentionally chopped off the end of one of his fingers
as a teenager. He has always had the desire to loose his whole hand but
could never bring himself to do it. My book gave him renewed energy in
this direction. He was a very successful business man and was well
known and respected in his community. He and his partner lived in an
expensive home. His life couldn't have been better, except for his
desire to be one-handed. He confided in me via e-mail, by telephone and
eventually we met in person. We discussed how he could fake an accident
to loose his hand. The actual act of losing the hand wasn't as
difficult as the task of how to stage the amputation so his many
friends would believe it was an accident He was well respected in his
community and wanted to continue this stature. He hadn't even expressed
his desire to his partner which further complicated the task.
Eventually we stopped corresponding. I suspect that he could not
bring himself to do it, in spite of his burning desire to be come
one-handed. He expressed this over and over to me in our conversions,
but could not find a way to have a convincing accident, or explain why
it might have been surgically removed. He even considered flying
to a foreign country where such procedures can be had in hospitals and
clinics. Money wasn't an issue for him, but the problem of explaining
it to the people he knew always came up.
The above stories illustrate the lengths to which AID inflicted
people will go to become amputees. AID sufferers live in all
parts of the world and come from all walks of life.
Self demand amputation is indeed a risky business. This
highlights the need for further research and understanding of this
condition. It is not known if this syndrome is hereditary or learned.
As we have heard, many recall seeing amputees at an early age which may
trigger the development of an AID condition. This was indeed my
situation. I can recall seeing a one-handed teen bag boy at a grocery
check-out counter when I was very young. I believe this was my trigger
Therapy alone does not always seem to cure this syndrome, but it
can help some deal with the amputation desire. The medical profession
has not yet reached the point where it will willingly preform elective
amputations in America. Physicians first basic principle is "to do your
patient no harm." They see amputation as debilitating. Hospitals
will not allow these procedures because of fear of adverse public
reaction. It is clear that the AID condition merits further
investigation and understanding.
Those who have accomplished a successful amputation usually
express great satisfaction with their new condition and seem to go on
to lead a fulfilled and happy new life style. In the case of Frank, he
says he wishes he had done it 20 years ago, rather than having waited
so long.
I cut off my hand some 30 years ago on a table saw. The picture
above is a re-creation. I have never had any regrets and have lead a
successful and happy life as a one-hander. I may well be the only one
to have ever come out about my elective amputation. My life has
been happy and successful so I decided there was no longer any reason
to hide my deed. My hope is to enlighten and be of some comfort to
others who have the same feelings as I. The world is not yet
ready for elective amputation but this is a start. Many forms of body
modification are now being undertaken and are becoming somewhat
accepted. Obviously being an amputee is not for everyone, but for those
who have this unusual desire, nothing short of a feigned accident will
relieve their long standing anxieties.
There is virtually nothing written on the subject of AID with
the exception of the book, Amputee Identity Disorder: information,
questions, answers, and recommendations about self-demand amputation,
by Greg M. Furth, Ph.D. & Robert Smith, ChM, FRCSEd, (2002.)
There was also a related website, www.biid.org.
In time, further research will undoubtedly lead to a
better understanding and acceptance of this condition and perhaps even
it's elimination all together. I welcome comments and discussion of
AID. You may reach me at ed@edstravels.us.
Books by Ed Cushman
Losing A Hand,
2002 BME Books (A revised hardcover edition is to be released soon)
Losing a Hand was written by Ed
over the past thirty years. It documents how he first came in contact
with amputee friends, and then tells of how he chose amputation for
himself and then with the aid of a power saw removed his own hand.
The book follows with stories of his adaptation - and
success - into amputee life. The lessons he learned and how they
learned them should be inspiring to all, but especially to those people
who know amputees or are amputees themselves, either by choice or by
fate. The book also contains many case studies of others who lost
one or more hands. It's written in a wonderful (and easy to read)
down-to-earth style and comes highly recommended.
Kai of Bonners Ferry,
2005 iuniverse
 Seventeen-year-old
Kai lost his hand when was three, but it didn't keep him from becoming
the head of his household when his grandfather died. He parents were
killed soon after he was born. Raised by his Grandparents, he grew up
to become a very capable young man who was an avid outdoor enthusiast,
radio announcer and out-of-body traveler. He was greatly admired by his
best teen friend Robin who soon decided he too wanted to become one
handed.
Kai's life became complicated when Anna, a Swedish exchange
student fell in love with him, and Robin said he loved Kai too. Kai Of Bonners Ferry brings to
light, the complicated and little-understood issue of AID, Amputee
Identity Disorder. The issue of self-demand amputation is explored in
order to better understand the feelings and motivations associated with
this syndrome. This story is fictional but is based on the personal
experiences of the author.
Ed Cushman is semi-retired and
currently a full-time campground host. He was born in Northern
Wisconsin and is an avid outdoors enthusiast. He maintains a daily web
page at edstravels.us. He cut off his hand on a table saw some
30 years ago.
Top
of Page Quest Home QNU Home
|